Today’s Truth

God’s kindness is intended to lead you to repentance. (Romans 2:4, CSB)

Friend to Friend

I sit across from a friend who knows me well. We’ve walked together for more than a decade. My eyes are tear-filled as I look at her and say, “I messed up.” I tell her of how I have failed in an area that has been an off-and-on battle in my life for years.

We all have one, don’t we? I call it our “Signature Struggle.” It’s the choice or habit or escape we go back to even though we know better. We swear we’ll never do that again—eat the whole pan of brownies or snap at the kids or drain the drink. But then we’re tired or stressed or overwhelmed and, suddenly, we do. No, sister, it isn’t just you. It’s all of us—every wandering, beating heart on this planet.

When I give in to my Signature Struggle, the critical voices in my mind are so loud: God will never use you now. You’re a hypocrite. You said you’d never do this again and now here you are. You’re a failure. You should give up.

On this morning as I sit with my friend, I think she should tell me the same. She should rebuke me and give me a Bible study to do immediately. She should issue a public announcement about my behavior so that others will be warned. Instead, she comes to sit beside me. She leans in and puts both arms around my shoulders. She says, so gently, “Don’t let the shame win. Don’t give the enemy that victory.”

She knows me well. She understands that I will recover from my misstep. I will get up and try again in the area of my Signature Struggle. I will make progress and move forward. I will learn from this mistake. What she is most concerned about is that I will let the shame take hold like a deadly viper sinking its fangs into my ankles. She’s seen what happens, how I pull back and hide. How I consider myself unworthy. How I distance myself from God like Adam and Eve hiding in the Garden.

She wisely understands what the enemy is really after is not simply to make us sin—the cross has already taken care of that—it’s to make us abandon our identity. It’s to convince us we cannot be both imperfect and loved at the same time. It’s to tempt us to believe our worst moments define us.

Later that day when the shame tries to slink in again, I close my eyes and picture my friend sitting next to me. Then I imagine that it’s Jesus instead. Because isn’t that how He loves us too? “God’s kindness is intended to lead you to repentance” (Romans 2:4).

The enemy of our hearts would always rather have us embrace shame and guilt instead of grace. Because grace is what transforms us, what brings us out of hiding, what gives us the courage to keep trying. It is the superpower that defeats our “Signature Struggle”, that snaps the fangs of the serpent. God wants to use the places where you’ve experienced the most shame to bring Him glory.

If you, like me, have recently given in to a Signature Struggle, then let me put my arms around your shoulders right now. Let me whisper again to both of us what my friend reminded me is true: We are still loved. Who we are in Christ hasn’t changed. We will rise. We will fight again. Grace always wins in the end.

Let’s Pray

Dear God, thank You for your kindness. Help me choose grace instead of guilt or shame! My identity is secure in You, and today I will choose to rest in Your love for me.
In Jesus’ Name, Amen.

Now It’s Your Turn

Take time today to write about who you are in Christ.

Here are a few examples: You are a beloved daughter, redeemed and chosen.

More from the Girlfriends

Holley Gerth learns something new every day about what it means to be truly loved by God. As a bestselling author she helps other women know how much they’re loved. She shares encouragement and truth through books like her devotional Strong, Brave, Loved: Empowering Reminders of Who You Really Are


© 2021 by Holley Gerth. All rights reserved.

9 Responses to “What Our Hearts Need When We Mess Up”

  1. Carolyn says:

    Thank You for writing about this! I was hoping I would hear from God about this, and through you, I did! Thank You

  2. Sherri says:

    Thank you!! I am imperfect and I know God is a forgiving God. But I beat myself up every time.
    Thank you for reminding me that I am LOVED in spite of my mess up!!
    Be blessed Sisters in Christ!!

  3. Bernadette says:

    These devotionals are life changing.

    When I struggle God is with me and He will never turn His back on me.

    I am chosen. I am a child of God

  4. Carol says:

    This reminder of Roman 2:4, is so perfect!
    Just yesterday, one of the pastor’s that I follow ( due to covid restrict.)stated a comment in his sermon: “Forgiven people…forgive people”
    Jesus is always there, to gently remind us; we mess-up but,He doesn’t give up!
    I was a choice of God, He patiently waited for me (30yrs. I might add), I’m broken, but not useless. I am a daughter of God! and Jesus is my Savior!

  5. Carola says:

    Soy amada♥️

  6. Terra says:

    Thank you, I needed to hear this for me and for my husband. We tend to take a lot of things to personally, and we need to remember the Lord forgives us and others as well. I sometimes am to harsh on myself and on him. Neither one of us is worthy, but the Lord loves us anyways. Hard to fathom some days.

  7. Melissa says:

    I feel I have failed my kids as a mom. Thank God he forgives me. Please pray my kids forgive me as well.

  8. Debbie says:

    I needed this message today! I praise God for His Grace! And your message!

  9. Cristina says:

    Thank for sharing your heart to us Christian sisters.
    Today I need to read a devotional just like this one.
    My signature struggle is a battle but I know the lord still loves me and will give me grace.

Leave a Reply

"We loved you so much that we were delighted to share with you not only the gospel of God but our lives as well…" 1 Thessalonians 2:8